Not gonna lie, U2 were a massive success and I also used to be a fan. This was based on reasonable-to-good talent, a real work ethic, and some flashes of genius. But that hardly explains how big they got – or how almost everyone later came to hate them.
What made the difference between a successful New Wave act and the stadium-filling globetrotters they were for a few decades was that they successfully over-leveraged their talents through a massive "parasocial" relationship with that big sweaty thing called "the world."
They pulled this off by tapping into the Irish diaspora in America and elsewhere, while avoiding being too "Oirish" in the rest of the World, and by wearing their, erm, "rock influences" prominently on their sleeves – see Rattle and Hum (1988).
Yeh, imagine that, going to Graceland and hanging out with JOHNNY CASH and BB KING. Most rock bands hadn’t thought it worthwhile signpost the obvious rock n' roll links to Blues, Country, and Gospel like that. As for their less marketable influences – The SKIDS, ECHO & the BUNNYMEN, paramilitary marching bands, etc. – those were left flapping in the wind.
The end result of all this was that after ruling the 80s and minting it in the 1990s, by the Zeroes the band had outlived its welcome to an epic degree, leading everybody and his dog to finally turn on Bono, who became the archetypal over-important wanker hobnobbing with the world's elites.
For the last 20 years or so, U2 have been taking that painful backwash of overleveraged popularity pretty squarely on the chin. Everything since 2004's How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb has sunk without a trace (which was a little unfair on 2009's No Line on the Horizon). But, now, there is a sense that the tide may be turning, and the time might be right to reposition the band as "(inter)national treasures" and milk the legend again. This seems to be the corporate impulse and vibe behind Carnaval de Luz, the sixteenth studio album by the Irish rockers.
The irritatingly Spanish title works both as a shout-out to some of their big secondary markets, but also as a signaller to their boomer base, who like being reminded of being on the holidays on the Costa del Sol, which also seems to be where the album cover is trying to go.
The all-too-obvious game plan with the album was to “make a U2 album that sounds like a u2 album,” and there is a sense that Carnaval is a return to form, or at least an uptick in a decades-long decline.
It is not a return to classic 80s form – they are simply too old for that– but it is definitely a late-career uptick.
Opener "Go (Carnaval de Luz)" is lightweight. It's mainly a 2-note computer input revved up in the studio for a couple of minutes. This is followed by "La Reina" a plodding thing that has some of the sonic textures of "Even Better Than the Real Thing" and "Zoo Station" disingenuously grafted onto it. I am not convinced by either of these tracks, while Bono’s lyrics, which once upon a time were quite good, seem something to avoid.
"Street of Dreams" is the first sign of life – upbeat and cheery. However, it sounds more like a girly pop song than anything, and the lyrics are cringe. It isn’t until track four and "The Mirror Maker (Rosalía)" that we finally get a guitar riff with a bit of bite and a decent bassline, rather than all the production BS and BRIAN ENOisms they have over-relied on for too long. Too bad the chorus sucks.
Next track "Superficiality" has a meaty, solid bass (thanks Adam). This almost makes you forgive Bono’s impression of TAKE THAT in the vocal department, where among other atrocities he needlessly spells out the song title.
The album then has a "senior moment" and wanders off to take a little nap. This manifest as the dire, preachy "If the World Is at War We Better Not Be." Not an actual song just Bono trying to get all intimate and breathy, backed up with a few sound effects.
I guess this is called "pacing" because next we get "Silencio" this album's "Vertigo" (from 2004's How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb) or, if you prefer, "Beautiful Day" (from 2000's All That You Can't Leave Behind). In other words a punchy, up-tempo "balls out" rocker "in the style of U2." The song-o is rather good-o and the energy’s there, but why not just knock the silly Spanish "o" off the end-o? The next track "The Greatest Show on Earth" comes across as a rendition of what they still mean to their die-hard fans. It's actually got a lot going for it and even sounds like "prime U2."
Except for the lyrics – which are all about how they used to be good but aren’t any more. Even though, ironically, this track shows that they could still be good if they could find something else to sing about besides being over-the-hill maudlin old fuckers.
The next song "Midnight Sunshine” is the best song on the album. Obviously planned as this album's "Wild Honey" (from 2000's All That You Can't Leave Behind) or 1997 B-Side "The Sweetest Thing," it breaks free and sounds fresher and more original than that. It ends up being the most authentic song on the album.
Next up, "Can't Stop Us Now" is also pretty good. Seagull guitar sounds over a burbling dirty bass, it scores high on authenticity too, despite being kind of nebulous and lost. Then the cheesy formula kicks back in, as they end with a posthumous duet with DOLLY PARTON. This is this album’s attempt at Zooropa’s "The Wanderer" with Johnny Cash, and provides a miserabilist depressing album closer. If U2 had just just told the record company suits to get stuffed, they might have made something better than this mild return to form.
Grade C+
Colin Liddell Revenge of Riff Raff 15th November, 2026
0 comments:
Post a Comment